The idea that culture can be property—intellectual property—is used to justify everything from attempts to force the Girl Scouts to pay royalties for singing songs around campfires to the infringement suit brought by the estate of Margaret Mitchell against the publishers of Alice Randall's The Wind Done Gone.
Intellectual property, defined to me as ones individual thoughts and emotions, is something that Lethem clearly criticizes by saying it's used to 'justify' such trivial and personal things such as a pack of Girl Scouts singing campfire songs, and has even gotten to the point where a genetics corporation known as Celera Genomics has started to patent certain genes. Upon reading that, I'm hit with this thought. Really? Someone out there has gone so far as to patent a gene? What happens when (and it must happen someday, for though there are infinite possible gene combinations, that one specific one will be picked one day) someone is born with those genes? Do they get sued for all the money they'll ever make in their whole life? It's stupid and useless.
An amusing and quite interesting anecdote that Lethem recites is the story of his first novel. Apparently, a very talented artist as a gift to Lethem had taken his very first novel and carved it onto a gun, which he then presented to Lethem. At this, Lethem says that he is lucky enough that the world has enough room for both his first novel in print and on a gun, and he doesn't need to pick between the two. In my opinion, this is sort of an ecstasy for him, perhaps a strange fetishistic (yes thats a real word, it's the adjective form of fetish, I looked it up) connection between him and his first novel. It's interesting to me that he can enjoy such a small victory.
I felt the same way when I read Letham's article. Plagiarism is so much more than we make it out to be. There are times when it is not bad at all. Some of the greatest works wouldn't have been made if not for plagiarism.
ReplyDeleteWhen you mentioned the face that a gene had been patented, I immediately thought of some cyborg world where humans were created by the use of proprietary standards. The fact that the patenting of genes is permitted could allow for such a world. I know that's a bit out there, but that's what came to mind. Why is it that organic material can become the property of organizations? It's madness!